Dairy Free Pumpkin Panna Cotta

Dairy Free Pumpkin Pie Panna Cotta - A creamy gelatin and coconut milk dessert, with classic fall and pumpkin pie flavors. | WorthCooking.net  Dairy Free Pumpkin Pie Panna Cottas - a simple and creamy fall dessert. |WorthCooking.net

Is it fall yet?

Can we pretend it is fall yet?

Great! Time to break out the pumpkin, and ginger, and cinnamon, and all those amazing fall flavors.

Just pretend last week I did not write about Strawberry Ice Cream that was perfect for summer. It is “fall” now. Time to try out the pumpkin pie panna cottas.

Dairy Free Pumpkin Pie Panna Cotta - A creamy gelatin and coconut milk dessert, with classic fall and pumpkin pie flavors. | WorthCooking.net

Before we go on, there is something you must know about me and fall (real or pretend). I think any breakfast/treat/dessert can be turned into gingerbread or pumpkin pie flavor. Oh, and I consider “pumpkin pie” and “gingerbread” an acceptable definition of a class of flavors. You have officially been warned.

My Pumpkin Pie Quinoa and my Pumpkin Pie/Brownie Combo of “Pumpkies” is evidence of this, and this blog has not even been around during fall time yet.

I tried to make these last year, and they turned out to be a lot harder than I expected.  To keep it dairy free I used coconut milk, which gets very thick in the fridge. So, I just was not sure how much gelatin to use to get that set, but jiggly texture that I hear is supposed to be a part of panna cotta.

Dairy Free Pumpkin Pie Panna Cotta - A creamy gelatin and coconut milk dessert, with classic fall and pumpkin pie flavors. | WorthCooking.net Confession: I had never even heard of this dessert until I was dairy free for my nursing daughter, so I think and hope this is the right texture and consistency. It seems to be what they describe when I was seeing it described on masterchef  researching it. Firm enough to cut through with a spoon, soft enough to jiggle. 

Even with my issues of getting the texture spot on, the taste always really wowed me. It really does taste like pumpkin pie, just with a slight coconut flavor and much creamier. It does not have as much puree in it (for the texture) but the flavor is definitely there.

I ended up deciding on reducing the amount of gelatin you would usually see in this amount of panna cotta. Since the milk gets pretty thick it has that luxurious texture straight out of the fridge.

Dairy Free Pumpkin Pie Panna Cotta - A creamy gelatin and coconut milk dessert, with classic fall and pumpkin pie flavors. | WorthCooking.net

Dairy Free Pumpkin Pie Panna Cotta
Serves: 6
  • 2 14oz cans full fat coconut milk
  • 1 cup pumpkin, or squash, puree
  • 2 teaspoons cinnamon
  • ¼ teaspoon allspice
  • ½ teaspoon dried, ground ginger
  • ½ scant teaspoon real salt
  • ¼ cup rapadura, sucanat, or blonde coconut sugar*
  • ⅓ cup honey*
  • 3 teaspoon gelatin
  • 2 teaspoons GF vanilla
  • *I have also done ¼ white sugar + maple syrup because I was out of both of these. I prefer the molasses to the maple flavor, but that is an option.
  1. Blend together the coconut milk, pumpkin, spices, salt, and sweeteners. Sprinkle the gelatin over the mixture and let bloom for 5 minutes.
  2. After blooming put the mixture in a small sauce pan and bring to a simmer over low- medium heat. Simmer, and stir, for about 3 minutes. Remove from the heat and stir in the vanilla.
  3. Pour into 6 wine glasses until nearly full.
  4. Let come to room temperature, than put it in the fridge. Refrigerate for at least 6 hours.
  5. Eat straight out of the fridge for the best texture. You can top with additional coconut sugar for an added molasses flavor or with coconut whipped cream.


sweet potatoes with sausage and arugula sauce

Sausage Stuffed Sweet Potatoes with Arugula Sauce

The Bit About Natalia Natalia’s poor face has been covered in varying degrees of eczema, and several of her classic reactions are back. It is getting worse before fully better. Each time the healing regresses it goes to being worse than it was before. I hope it does not get as bad as we have seen… 

Read More »

avocado pudding dessert

5 Tips to Get More Vegetables + Vegetables for Breakfast Ideas

Happy Wednesday everyone! I hope your week is going lovely. As many of you might know, I have a passion for vegetables. I think they are often overlooked as delicious cuisine, which I find so sad because they really can be delicious. So, I am always on the look out for ways to not just… 

Read More »

spanish quinoa 3

Spanish Quinoa

I like my rice. One problem though…I really do try to limit our refined grains so the whole white rice thing has been bothering me. I grew up with brown rice but switched to white a few years ago, and just can’t get used to most brown rice again. I have found that if I bake… 

Read More »

strawberry ice cream 3

Quick & Healthy Strawberry Soft Serve

What’s this? Two easy and healthy treats in one week? And on a cooking blog? I was going to share a Mexican version of my Spiced Ginger Chicken today. On Monday I spent hours perfecting the recipe while taking meticulous notes. I was a little stressed by the fact that I was doing it “last minute” and… 

Read More »

bbq chicken wraps -tnh

Slow Cooker Chicken Lettuce Wraps + Creamy Avocado Pudding

I realize that that might be the most random title ever. But, something must be done. 1. I don’t want you to miss out on the recipes I have posted elsewhere in the great blogosphere. 2. I don’t want to take up two days this week just to tell you about them, and where to… 

Read More »

chocolate mint truffles 3

{Healthy} Chocolate Mint Truffles

So, the kids were watching me edit the photos for these: Valerie *squeals* *signs eat* *stares at photos* *squeals* *signs eat* *repeats until I pretend to give her a bite from the photo I was editing* *pretends to take the bites I hands her. Smacks lips* *repeats sequence* (she did not get to try the… 

Read More »


Shiitake Mushroom & Chicken Stir Fry

Every week at our local farmer’s market I splurge on a few ounces of locally grown shiitake mushrooms. It is generally my highlight purchase. (Though, basil gets me pretty excited too!) For me, that is about as exotic as I have ever gotten. Does that mean I am incredibly boring in the kitchen? I hope… 

Read More »

super hero snacks

Super Snacks (super easy + super nutritious + satisfying super appetites)

Being a super hero is very serious business. Well, I guess it depends on the super hero.   Super (Hero) Appetites I have a five, three, and one year old. There is never a dull, or much more so, a still moment. It is always go, go, go. Be it tickling the baby mercilessly, saving the… 

Read More »

How to make REAL Kosher Dill Pickles (no vinegar and probiotic rich) | WorthCooking.net

How To Make Real Kosher Dill Pickles

Over the last few years I have taken in an obscene amount of information about food. Cooking food. Nutrition. Cooking for allergies. Recipe testing. Et cetera, et cetera. If I were to point to one specific thing I have learned about that surpasses the rest in incredible-ness it would be learning about pickling. Not just… 

Read More »

chicken and noodle stew

Chicken and Noodle Stew

Every so often I decide it is time to throw out (most) of my thoughts on nutrition and go for comfort level 10. This almost always brings me to some sort of carb-y chicken stew or soup. I still try and go for whole grains in times like these. At least that is something, right?… 

Read More »